← ALL NEWS
TRADEMARKJUDGMENT/EVENT DATE: 5 November 2026PUBLISHED: 16 November 2026

High Court allows Victoria’s Secret US trademark action to continue

The English High Court has refused Thomas Pink’s application to stop Victoria’s Secret pursuing US trademark infringement proceedings. It held that the disputed products fell outside the protection of the businesses’ worldwide coexistence agreement.

The English High Court has rejected Thomas Pink’s attempt to prevent Victoria’s Secret from pursuing a US trademark infringement action over PINK-branded clothing. In a judgment handed down on 5 November 2026, Deputy Judge Justin Turner KC considered a settlement agreement signed by the parties’ predecessors on 27 July 2015. The court refused an anti-suit injunction, allowing proceedings in the Southern District of Ohio to continue because the disputed products fell outside the agreement’s protection.

The agreement followed earlier litigation between the businesses. In 2014, Mr Justice Birss found that Victoria’s Secret had infringed Thomas Pink’s UK and EU trademark rights by using PINK on retail stores and clothing. Victoria’s Secret obtained permission to appeal, but the proceedings were subsequently settled. The resulting worldwide coexistence agreement established reciprocal restrictions on when the businesses could assert their respective trademark rights against one another, subject to specified exceptions.

The latest dispute focused on clause 5.5, particularly subclause 5.5.2. This created an exception to Victoria’s Secret’s undertaking not to assert its rights where PINK was used with a brand or product range associated with a brand or business other than the THOMAS PINK business. The dispute arose after Victoria’s Secret discovered women’s athleisure clothing on the US market in August 2026 with PINK prominently displayed on the exterior. The ruling concerns whether the agreement prevents the US action, rather than deciding that action’s infringement allegations.

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR COVER

For defence and pursuit planning, this dispute shows why a coexistence agreement should not be treated as eliminating future trademark litigation risk. Businesses should check whether proposed cover addresses the relevant territories and proceedings involving settlement agreements, rather than assume those issues are covered.

DEFENCE UP TO £5M · PURSUIT UP TO £1M IN YEAR ONE · PURSUIT ONLY WITH DEFENCE

SOURCE: The Trademark Lawyer

Summarised for general information only. Nothing here is legal advice or a statement of policy terms – cover is subject to underwriting and the policy wording.