Thomas Pink fails to block Victoria’s Secret US trade mark claim
The High Court refused Thomas Pink’s application to stop Victoria’s Secret pursuing a US infringement claim over externally branded PINK womenswear. The court found that internal THOMAS PINK labels did not bring the external branding within the protection claimed under the parties’ 2015 settlement.
On 5 November 2026, Deputy Judge Justin Turner KC refused an anti-suit injunction sought by Thomas Pink in the High Court of England and Wales. The injunction would have prevented Victoria’s Secret from continuing its infringement claim in Ohio over womenswear displaying PINK prominently on the outside. Thomas Pink relied on internal THOMAS PINK labels, but the court found that these did not protect the external PINK branding from challenge under the companies’ settlement. Whether the goods infringe US trade marks remains for the US court.
The dispute follows earlier litigation in which Mr Justice Birss found in 2014 that Victoria’s Secret had infringed Thomas Pink’s trade marks through its use of PINK on shops and clothing in the UK and continental Europe. Victoria’s Secret obtained permission to appeal, but the parties settled on 27 July 2015. Their agreement resolved disputes worldwide and restricted the circumstances in which either could enforce trade marks against the other, with exceptions for particular products and uses.
Victoria’s Secret already had a substantial US business under PINK when the agreement was signed. There was no evidence that Thomas Pink had then sold US products under that mark. In August 2026, Victoria’s Secret discovered Thomas Pink’s US women’s sports-leisure range and sued in the Southern District of Ohio. Because the settlement required interpretation disputes to be decided by English courts, both companies brought English claims in September, which were heard together on 20 October.
This case shows why a prior settlement should not be treated as eliminating future defence exposure, particularly when products and territories differ. Businesses reviewing defence or pursuit cover should check how the policy treats settlement-related disputes and proceedings in overseas courts.
DEFENCE UP TO £5M · PURSUIT UP TO £1M IN YEAR ONE · PURSUIT ONLY WITH DEFENCE
SOURCE: ICLG
Summarised for general information only. Nothing here is legal advice or a statement of policy terms – cover is subject to underwriting and the policy wording.
