← ALL NEWS
PATENTJUDGMENT/EVENT DATE: 12 October 2026PUBLISHED: 12 October 2026

Emotional Perception AI patent refused again after Supreme Court appeal

The UKIPO has again refused Emotional Perception AI Limited’s patent application following its successful Supreme Court appeal. The latest decision concludes that the application does not meet patentability requirements, including inventive step.

The UK Intellectual Property Office has again refused Emotional Perception AI Limited’s application for an artificial neural network-based media recommendation system. The decision follows the Supreme Court’s February 2026 judgment in Emotional Perception AI Ltd v Comptroller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks. Although the company succeeded before the Supreme Court, the application returned to the UKIPO for further assessment and has now failed to satisfy patentability requirements, including inventive step.

Application GB1904713.3 concerns a system that generates media recommendations using similarities between files. It trains an artificial neural network using both natural-language descriptions and objectively measurable physical properties. Once trained, the network uses physical properties to recommend files intended to produce a similar emotional response to an input file. A UKIPO hearing officer originally refused the application in 2022 under the exclusion for computer programs ‘as such’. The High Court allowed an appeal, but the Court of Appeal reinstated the refusal in 2024.

The Supreme Court unanimously allowed the company’s appeal in February 2026. It held that the network was a computer program, but that the claims had technical character because the network necessarily operated using hardware. The Court rejected the established Aerotel methodology and adopted the European Patent Office framework in G1/19. However, it left the ‘intermediate step’ and inventive-step assessment to the UKIPO. The renewed refusal illustrates the distinction between overcoming the computer-program exclusion and satisfying the remaining requirements for a patent.

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR COVER

For businesses considering pursuit cover, this dispute highlights why a successful appeal on one patentability issue should not be mistaken for an enforceable patent. GMG’s pursuit cover is available only alongside defence cover, with limits up to £1m in year one for pursuit and up to £5m for defence.

DEFENCE UP TO £5M · PURSUIT UP TO £1M IN YEAR ONE · PURSUIT ONLY WITH DEFENCE

SOURCE: The Patent Lawyer Magazine

Summarised for general information only. Nothing here is legal advice or a statement of policy terms – cover is subject to underwriting and the policy wording.