Emotional Perception AI patent ruling prompts UK examination changes
The Court of Appeal overturned a High Court decision finding Emotional Perception AI’s artificial neural network invention patentable. The Legal 500 reports that the Supreme Court has granted permission to appeal and that the ruling has prompted revised UK patent examination guidelines.
The Court of Appeal’s decision in Emotional Perception AI Ltd v Comptroller-General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks [2024] EWCA Civ 825 reversed an earlier High Court finding that the company’s artificial neural network invention was patentable. The dispute concerns patentability rather than an infringement claim against a competing business. According to the Legal 500 article published on 31 January 2025, Emotional Perception has been granted permission to appeal to the UK Supreme Court.
The article reports that the UK Intellectual Property Office updated its guidelines for examining artificial intelligence patent applications on 30 January 2025, following the Court of Appeal ruling. The changes are intended to bring examination guidance into line with the current law. They address the threshold for demonstrating a technical contribution beyond the mere implementation of an abstract idea in software, with substantive amendments across several sections of the guidance.
The report also highlights an important qualification: the revised guidelines may themselves be superseded following the Supreme Court appeal. It reports permission to appeal, not a Supreme Court decision on the merits. For organisations seeking patent protection for AI inventions, the concrete development is therefore a reversal of the earlier patentability finding and a corresponding change in examination guidance, while a further appeal remains possible. The supplied article does not give an exact date for either court’s decision.
This patentability dispute should not be treated as evidence that defence or pursuit insurance covers patent application appeals – the scope of any cover needs checking. GMG offers defence cover up to £5m and pursuit cover up to £1m in year one, with pursuit available only alongside defence.
DEFENCE UP TO £5M · PURSUIT UP TO £1M IN YEAR ONE · PURSUIT ONLY WITH DEFENCE
SOURCE: The Legal 500
Summarised for general information only. Nothing here is legal advice or a statement of policy terms – cover is subject to underwriting and the policy wording.
