High Court rejects £100,000 AI image search in B&Q and Wren trade mark dispute
The UK High Court refused Wren Kitchens’ proposed AI-assisted image search in its ongoing trade mark dispute with B&Q. The court found the estimated £100,000 disclosure exercise disproportionate to its likely evidential value.
The UK High Court has rejected Wren Kitchens’ request to use an artificial intelligence tool to search for further image-based evidence in its dispute with B&Q. In B&Q Limited v. Wren Kitchens Limited [2026] EWHC 2552 (BP), handed down on 8 October 2026, Deputy High Court Judge David Stone found the proposed exercise disproportionate. His decision reflected its estimated £100,000 cost and the apparent unlikelihood of finding relevant additional material.
B&Q began proceedings in March 2022, alleging trade mark infringement over comparative kitchen-price advertising. The challenged advertisements included claims that ‘Wren costs less than B&Q’ and that Wren’s kitchens cost between 3% and 35% less. B&Q also alleges breaches of the Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008. Wren denies infringement and maintains that its comparisons were accurate. Its counterclaims concern B&Q’s use of comparison tables from the Kitchen Compare website, whose independence Wren disputes.
Earlier disclosure searches used text-based methods across documents from 30 B&Q stores. Wren argued that these could overlook trade marks appearing in images rather than searchable text. Its proposed AI search would cover those stores over a four-week period in March 2021, using a proprietary tool launched in January 2025. Although the estimated cost had fallen from £400,000 to approximately £100,000, the court refused the request. The decision does not prohibit AI-assisted evidence gathering – it illustrates the court’s assessment of the cost and likely value of expanding disclosure.
For businesses considering defence or pursuit cover, this dispute highlights the importance of planning for contested disclosure and scrutiny of evidence-gathering costs. GMG offers defence cover up to £5m and pursuit cover up to £1m in year one, with pursuit available only alongside defence, but this ruling does not establish whether any particular expense would be insured.
DEFENCE UP TO £5M · PURSUIT UP TO £1M IN YEAR ONE · PURSUIT ONLY WITH DEFENCE
SOURCE: The Trademark Lawyer Magazine
Summarised for general information only. Nothing here is legal advice or a statement of policy terms – cover is subject to underwriting and the policy wording.
