← ALL NEWS
PATENTJUDGMENT/EVENT DATE: 29 October 2026PUBLISHED: 9 November 2026

Motorola loses US evidence appeal in European patent dispute

The US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed an order allowing Motorola to obtain confidential patent acquisition documents for European infringement proceedings. It found that the request risked circumventing evidence-gathering decisions already made in those proceedings.

On 29 October 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit overturned a district court order granting Motorola access to an unredacted patent purchase agreement. In Motorola Mobility, L.L.C. v. Advanced Standard Communication, L.L.C., the court found that the district court had misapplied the legal standards governing cross-border discovery under Section 1782 of the US Code. That provision allows US federal courts to order evidence production for use in foreign or international proceedings.

Advanced Standard Communication (ASC) acquired the telecommunications patent portfolio from ZTE Corporation on 31 December 2022. ASC subsequently brought infringement proceedings against Motorola concerning three patents allegedly covering technology required to manufacture 5G-capable devices. One action was brought before the Unified Patent Court and two before Munich District Court I. Motorola primarily denied infringement, while also arguing that any patents found infringed would need to be licensed on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms.

Motorola sought the purchase agreement and accompanying exhibits to support its FRAND defence, arguing that they could inform patent valuation and the assessment of ASC’s licensing demands. The public agreement was redacted and omitted an exhibit referring to licences. Motorola applied for US discovery in December 2025, initially seeking five categories of documents. By the appeal, only the unredacted agreement and its exhibits remained contested. The appellate court found that the request risked circumventing evidence-gathering decisions in the parallel European proceedings.

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR COVER

The dispute highlights why businesses considering patent defence cover should examine its territorial scope and treatment of ancillary evidence proceedings. GMG offers defence cover up to £5m, but whether particular proceedings fall within cover depends on the policy terms.

DEFENCE UP TO £5M · PURSUIT UP TO £1M IN YEAR ONE · PURSUIT ONLY WITH DEFENCE

SOURCE: The Patent Lawyer Magazine

Summarised for general information only. Nothing here is legal advice or a statement of policy terms – cover is subject to underwriting and the policy wording.