US Supreme Court leaves worldwide copyright termination ruling intact
The US Supreme Court left the Fifth Circuit’s decision in Vetter v Resnik intact on 19 October 2026. The ruling allows qualifying songwriters to reclaim worldwide rights through US copyright termination, challenging the assumption that foreign rights remain with publishers.
The US Supreme Court left standing the Fifth Circuit’s decision in Vetter v Resnik on 19 October 2026. According to Arnall Golden Gregory’s report, the appeal court held that a songwriter’s termination of an earlier rights deal could reclaim rights worldwide, rather than solely within the United States. The development leaves worldwide termination rights available in the Fifth Circuit and raises questions for songwriters, heirs, publishers and music catalogue buyers.
The dispute concerned ‘Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love)’, written by Cyril Vetter and Donald Smith. Vetter transferred his rights in the song to a music publisher in 1963. Decades later, he invoked section 304(c) of the US Copyright Act, which allows authors to cancel qualifying older rights deals after a prescribed period and recover their rights. A federal court in Louisiana ruled that the rights recovered extended worldwide. In January 2026, the Fifth Circuit agreed.
The report contrasts that outcome with the music industry’s longstanding assumption that US statutory termination returns only US rights, leaving foreign rights with the publisher. It identifies ownership and valuation uncertainty for publishers and catalogue investors, particularly where older agreements cover worldwide rights. It also recommends reassessing termination eligibility, jurisdiction and foreign rights before negotiating or acquiring catalogues. The reported Supreme Court event left the lower court’s decision intact; it should not be described as a new Supreme Court ruling on the merits of worldwide termination.
For defence cover, the dispute highlights the need to review whether ownership and termination claims involving overseas rights fall within the policy’s scope. For pursuit cover, authors seeking to recover rights should likewise check eligibility rather than assume that a statutory termination dispute is covered.
DEFENCE UP TO £5M · PURSUIT UP TO £1M IN YEAR ONE · PURSUIT ONLY WITH DEFENCE
SOURCE: Arnall Golden Gregory
Summarised for general information only. Nothing here is legal advice or a statement of policy terms – cover is subject to underwriting and the policy wording.
